46 Peanut Butters Ranked: The Surprising Winners (and a Jar That Tasted Rotten)

Babish tastes and scores every major peanut butter brand on the market — from Skippy and Jif to natural, flavored, and powdered varieties. Highlights include shocking rancidity in the Peter Pan lineup, a runny peanut butter served from a wine glass, and Peanut Butter & Co.'s Cinnamon Swirl claiming the top spot. Two kid guest judges break a three-way tie for third place.